Blog

Opening a container of coating that’s been stored for a few months, only to find a layer of liquid on top and hard lumps at the bottom — this is one of the most frustrating quality issues for coating manufacturers. Separation ruins the opening effect, and severe hard settling can even render an entire batch unusable. What causes it? And how do you fix it?

Coating separation isn’t just one problem — there are three common types:

• Water separation: Clear or light yellow liquid appears on the surface, caused by the shrinkage and detachment of the water-phase thickening network.

• Emulsion separation: Milky white liquid separates to the top, caused by emulsion particles detaching from the system and floating upward.

• Settling: Hard sediment forms at the bottom, common in high-density pigment/filler systems.

The root cause is straightforward. Pigment and filler particles sink under gravity, and van der Waals forces between particles cause them to agglomerate and grow larger, accelerating the settling rate. According to Stokes’ Law, settling velocity is proportional to the square of particle size and inversely proportional to system viscosity. In simple terms: the larger the particles and the lower the viscosity, the faster they settle.

Thickeners don’t just make the coating thicker. Different types work through different mechanisms:

• Cellulosic thickeners (e.g., HEC) — Highly efficient at thickening the water phase, increasing low-shear viscosity, and imparting thixotropy to prevent sedimentation during storage. However, used alone, water separation can be significant.

• Alkali-swellable thickeners (ASE/HASE) — Activated under alkaline conditions, they increase low-shear viscosity and provide good anti-settling and anti-water-separation performance. But they may cause post-thickening when used alone.

• Associative polyurethane thickeners (HEUR) — Hydrophobic groups adsorb onto emulsion or pigment/filler particle surfaces, forming bridging networks between particles to prevent settling. However, any sediment that forms tends to be hard and difficult to remix.

• Inorganic thickeners (bentonite, fumed silica) — Form a 3D “card-house” structure in water, creating thixotropic behavior that is highly effective against hard settling. Fumed silica builds a nano-network throughout the system via hydrogen bonds, effectively “holding up” pigments and fillers.

No single thickener does it all. The industry consensus is: use blends. Tests show that a combination of a small amount of HEC with alkali-swellable and polyurethane thickeners produces a uniform state with neither sediment nor water separation. Recommended blend: HEC (0.2%-0.5%) + HEUR (0.1%-0.3%) to balance water-phase thickening and particle adsorption.

Three key takeaways for anti-settling with thickeners:

• Thicker isn’t better — the key is building a proper low-shear viscosity network.

• Blends outperform single thickeners — the HEC + ASE + HEUR combination works best.

• Test, don’t guess — every batch formula must be validated through storage stability testing.